Is Shaking a Can With Coins Bad for Dogs


No Comments

I've always wondered if shaking a can with coins is harmful to dogs. Well, the answer is not as simple as it seems.

In this article, we'll explore the controversy surrounding this training technique and delve into the potential negative effects it may have on our furry friends.

Additionally, we'll discuss the behavioral impact of can shaking and provide alternative methods for dog training.

So, let's dig deeper and uncover what the experts have to say about this hotly debated topic.

The Controversy Surrounding Can Shaking

From my experience, I've noticed that there's a significant controversy surrounding the act of shaking a can with coins. Public opinion is divided on whether this method of training is effective or harmful to animals.

While some argue that it's a harmless way to discourage unwanted behavior, others believe it can cause fear and anxiety in animals. This controversy has also led to discussions about the legal implications of using such training methods. Some jurisdictions have even banned the use of shaking cans altogether, considering it a form of animal cruelty.

It's important to consider both sides of the argument and to explore alternative training methods that are more positive and humane. Ultimately, the controversy surrounding can shaking raises important questions about the ethics and effectiveness of certain training techniques.

Potential Negative Effects on Dogs

Shaking a can with coins can have potential negative effects on dogs. It's important to understand that while this method may be used as a training tool by some, there are negative consequences to consider.

The loud noise created by shaking the can can cause physical discomfort for dogs, especially those with sensitive hearing. The sudden startle and fear response can lead to anxiety and stress in our furry friends.

See also  Do Dog Whiskers Grow Back

Additionally, the association between the sound of shaking coins and negative experiences can create a lasting aversion or fear of similar noises. It's crucial to prioritize the well-being and emotional health of our dogs, and to explore alternative, positive reinforcement-based training methods that don't cause unnecessary physical discomfort.

Behavioral Impact of Shaking a Can With Coins

The noise of shaking a can with coins can have a significant impact on a dog's behavior. Can shaking has been known to cause anxiety in dogs, as the sudden loud sound can startle and frighten them. This can lead to a range of behavioral issues, including fear aggression.

When a dog is constantly exposed to the sound of a can shaking, it can associate the noise with negative experiences and become more reactive and aggressive in certain situations. This can be particularly problematic if the dog's fear aggression is directed towards humans or other animals. Understanding the behavioral impact of can shaking is crucial in order to effectively train and manage dogs.

Now, let's explore some alternatives to using a can with coins for dog training, which can be equally effective without causing any harm or distress to our furry friends.

Alternatives to Using a Can With Coins for Dog Training

I've found some effective alternatives for training dogs without using a can filled with coins.

Dogs can be sensitive to loud noises, so it's important to consider their noise sensitivity when training them.

One alternative to the can with coins method is using positive reinforcement methods. Instead of punishing unwanted behavior, focus on rewarding good behavior. For example, when your dog follows a command correctly, reward them with treats, praise, or playtime. This positive reinforcement helps dogs associate good behavior with positive outcomes, making them more likely to repeat it.

See also  Can Dogs Eat Ritz Crackers? A Veterinarian's Take on Whether or Not It's Safe

Another alternative is using clicker training. This involves using a clicker to make a distinct noise when your dog does something correctly, followed by a reward. This method helps dogs understand what behavior is being rewarded and encourages them to repeat it.

Expert Recommendations on Can Shaking and Dog Training

One expert recommends using alternative training methods instead of shaking a can with coins to avoid potentially negative effects on dogs. Positive reinforcement techniques in dog training are highly recommended by experts as they focus on rewarding desired behaviors rather than punishing unwanted ones. These techniques involve using treats, praise, and other rewards to encourage dogs to repeat behaviors that are desired. By providing positive reinforcement, dogs are motivated to learn and participate in the training process.

Consistency is also crucial in dog training methods. Dogs thrive on routine and predictability, so it's important to establish clear and consistent rules and expectations. This helps dogs understand what's expected of them and reduces confusion or uncertainty. When training a dog, it's essential to use the same commands, signals, and rewards consistently to reinforce desired behaviors and discourage unwanted ones. By being consistent in our training methods, we can effectively communicate with our dogs and achieve positive results.


In conclusion, it's advisable to avoid shaking a can with coins when training dogs due to the potential negative effects on their behavior. Instead, it's recommended to explore alternative methods that are more gentle and effective.

Seeking guidance from experts in dog training can provide valuable insights and ensure the well-being of our furry companions. Let's strive for training techniques that promote positive reinforcement and strengthen the bond between humans and dogs.



Dog Ownership Guide – D.O.G. – launched in 2021 to meet the needs of dog owners and their dogs worldwide. Our website is a place to not only learn, shop, and entertain, but share as well. Leave a comment, contact us, or learn more about the founder.

Leave a Comment