If you’re a dog owner, you may have heard of the technique of shaking a can with coins to get your dog’s attention or discourage certain behaviors. But is it a safe and effective method? The answer is not straightforward and depends on several factors.
Some proponents of shaking a can with coins argue that it is a harmless and efficient way to get your dog’s attention when they are misbehaving or not responding to your commands. The noise created by the can and coins is supposed to startle the dog and interrupt their current behavior. However, opponents of this technique claim that it can have negative consequences on a dog’s mental and emotional well-being.
Is Shaking a Can with Coins Bad for Dogs
Shaking a can with coins is a common technique used by dog owners to get their dog’s attention or to discourage unwanted behavior. However, the question arises whether shaking a can with coins is bad for dogs or not.
When you shake a can with coins, it creates a loud and sudden noise that startles your dog. This may cause fear, anxiety, and stress in your dog, especially if it is done repeatedly or with excessive force. Puppies or dogs with a fear response may start shivering or trembling upon hearing the sound.
Furthermore, shaking a can with coins may lead to aggressive behavior in some dogs. It can create a negative association with the sound and the person who is shaking the can, leading to biting or other unwanted behavior.
Positive reinforcement techniques, such as clicker training or praise, are more effective and humane ways to train your dog. Punishment or negative reinforcement, such as shaking a can with coins, may cause discomfort, distress, and injury to your dog.
If you want to use a can with coins to get your dog’s attention, it is essential to desensitize your dog to the sound gradually. Start by shaking the can softly and from a distance, then gradually increase the volume and proximity. Always reward your dog with treats or praise when they respond positively to the sound.
It is crucial to note that shaking a can with coins is not an effective way to deter your dog from eating or chewing something poisonous, such as chocolate or xylitol. In such cases, you should contact your veterinarian immediately.
In summary, shaking a can with coins may cause fear, anxiety, and aggressive behavior in some dogs. Positive reinforcement techniques are a more effective and humane way to train your dog. If you decide to use a can with coins, desensitize your dog gradually and always reward positive behavior.
